All About Heirloom Tomatoes

Ideas for serving and cooking with the many types of heirloom tomatoes.

heirloom tomato varieties / loveandlemons.com

I’m hoping you’re not tomato-ed out yet! Today, I want to share a little info & inspiration about a few heirloom tomato varieties. (These are the ones I used in last week’s salad). They have such fun names, don’t they?

And for more recipe ideas, check out the Whole Foods heirloom tomato pinboard that I’ve been pinning to over the last few weeks:

heirloom tomato pinboard
image sources: midwest living / mission delectable / a couple cooks
foodie crush / whole foods market / the devil wears parsley

( This giveaway is now closed. )
Win a $50 Whole Foods gift card. Just leave a comment below telling me about your favorite way to eat heirloom tomatoes!

This post is in partnership with Whole Foods Market. Thank you for supporting the sponsors that support Love & Lemons. Giveaway ends 8/22/13. Open to US residents only.

283 comments

  1. Lauren from champagnereveries.blogspot.com
    08.19.2013

    I’m pretty simple. I love heirloom tomatoes with fresh mozz, basil, a bit of salt and olive oil. Yum!

  2. Heidi Babi from diyandlivetotell.blogspot.com
    08.19.2013

    In a simple caprese salad: Thick slices of tomato, slice of fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, and balsamic vinegar drizzled lightly over the top.

  3. Nancy
    08.19.2013

    Definitely with fresh moz, s+p, basil, and good olive oil.

  4. lesley
    08.19.2013

    Sliced on sourdough toast with just a little bit of Kewpie mayo and pinch salt and pepper. Simple and delicious!

  5. Emily
    08.19.2013

    Is it weird if I just bite into ’em like an apple? I also love them on top of garlic crostini with goat cheese and a drizzle of lemon infused olive oil!

  6. Julie
    08.19.2013

    Simply. Just sliced with a slight sprinkle of salt…..

  7. megan from thelifeofmegananne.blogspot.com
    08.19.2013

    with just a sprinkle of salt!

  8. chelsy from mangiablog.com
    08.19.2013

    I love to slice them into medium thick slices, sprinkle w/ salt and pepper and top w/ my homemade tzatziki sauce and a good crumble of feta cheese. It’s a perfect snack or appetizer before a meal 🙂

  9. Heirloom tomatoes remind me so much of my mom… coming home in the summer and seeing a plate of blood red tomatoes, thickly sliced, stacked and salted. I still prefer them this way… so simple. The hearty pinch of salt just lets the tomato shine all on its own while it’s in season.

  10. felicia
    08.19.2013

    Paella with tomatoes from Mark Bittman’s recipe. The addition of smoked paprika makes it absolutely divine!!

    • jeanine
      08.19.2013

      ooh I’ll have to try that…

  11. Sally from sallycooks.com
    08.19.2013

    You can’t beat them with salt, pepper and some good olive oil! Lovely photos!

  12. I love showcasing the Heirloom beauties and subtle flavor differences between them by serving them simply. I always try to recreate my most precious food memories of my time in Italy by slicing them and serving them drizzled with the best olive oil, sea salt, fragrant basil, and fresh mozzarella. An accompaniment of rustic crusty bread, roasted red peppers, olives, and capers is always welcomed.

  13. shannon
    08.19.2013

    in a galette!

  14. Halley Johnson
    08.19.2013

    Gotta chime in and say that sliced, with sea salt and fresh black pepper is the absolute best way to go. Although it’s a tradition in my family to have bacon & tomato sandwiches in the summer – just white bread, mayo, thick bacon and sliced tomato. No lettuce for us Arkansans!

  15. Kelsey Wittenberg
    08.19.2013

    I can’t do anything more to heirlooms than to just top with S&P, olive oil and basil chiffonade. But if it’s around, I would slather it with burrata cheese and call it a day with a glass of chard.

  16. kristine
    08.19.2013

    my favorite way to use heirlooms? super simple–the perfect caprese sandwich, complete with crusty, toasty bread, homemade pesto, fresh basil leaves from the garden and thick slices of buffalo mozzarella. yum!

  17. Nate
    08.19.2013

    I have to say that I agree with Jenn. The best way to enjoy a good ripe tomato is simply seasoned. Dressing it up with some fresh herbs and good, mild cheese (so as not to overpower the flavor of a prime tomato) hits the spot, as well. Gotta love tomato season!

  18. Heather
    08.19.2013

    Is it a cop-out if my response is simply thick slices with a sprinkling of salt and pepper?

    • jeanine
      08.19.2013

      ha, not a cop-out! Simple is sometimes best!

  19. Andi from mysistersknitter.typepad.com
    08.19.2013

    Tomatoes are my favorite food ever. Heirlooms are like the cherry on top. It may sounds boring but my most favorite way to eat them is as a snack. No salt, no dressing, just as they are.
    Of course salads, in pasta, and sandwiches are lovely as well. But nothing beats eating them as they are.

  20. Jenn from vanillalemon.com
    08.19.2013

    Sliced, with the best burrata, and drizzled with olive oil, fresh lemon juice, and a pinch of salt and pepper!

    • Laura
      08.19.2013

      I love sliced tomato with some s & p, a drizzle of very good evoo and a drizzle of balsalic served with burrata, Sometimes just a slice of really good bread with some homemade mayo and thick slices of tomato and a couple of pieces of bacon. Now I have to go make lunch!

    • CJ
      08.19.2013

      My favorite way to serve is to cut them up on a platter with various colors and sizes. Add some avocado and red onion and drizzle with balsamic and olive oil. Then rub minced herbs (oregano, basil, thyme) into Ricotta Salata and sprinkle over the top. YUM!

    • Meg S
      08.19.2013

      I love them straight out of the garden! Wash them with the hose and take a nice bite like an apple. Otherwise just about any form will do but I have my eye on a few Tomato Garlic Tarts that I would like to try – hmmm goat cheese, mozzarella, feta or ricotta?

    • Carly from carlydefilippo.com
      08.20.2013

      Pappa al pomodoro. Nothing is better than this simple soup of crushed heirloom tomatoes, poured over bits of toasted, salvaged stale bread. A few fresh herbs and a drizzle of herbaceous extra virgin olive oil…la cucina povera perfetta!

    • Amy D
      08.20.2013

      …with a knife

    • andrea
      08.20.2013

      Simply – with fresh basil, slices of good mozzarella and drizzled with a balsamic reduction. Sprinkle of sea salt and pepper for a little kick!

    • Aaron Turner
      08.21.2013

      Sliced with a little salt and pepper! MMHHMMM! No need to dress up a good tomato.

    • Michelle
      08.21.2013

      I love fresh tomatoes! Romesco sauce is my current addiction-blending up tomatoes with fresh basil, almonds, and lots of garlic with a few spices and tossing with brown rice pasta…it’s exquisite!

A food blog with fresh, zesty recipes.
Photograph of Jeanine Donofrio and Jack Mathews in their kitchen

Hello, we're Jeanine and Jack.

We love to eat, travel, cook, and eat some more! We create & photograph vegetarian recipes from our home in Chicago, while our shiba pups eat the kale stems that fall on the kitchen floor.